Dailymaverick logo

Business Maverick

This article is more than a year old

Business Maverick

After the Bell: Ireland’s not being a good sport about its visa push

Irish eyes might be smiling, but South Africans are rightly rankled by Ireland’s new visa requirements, imposed on Monday with a tiny bone thrown our way by way of a ‘grace period’ that is probably of use to only a minuscule cohort of travellers.
After the Bell: Ireland’s not being a good sport about its visa push

‘Rugby Fan” said it best: “Jeez, beat them in one rugby game, and they go nuts.” 

Jokes aside, it’s not about sour grapes stemming from Saturday’s Test match when the Boks beat Ireland 27-20. 

Nor is it just that South Africans and Botswanans must now apply for a visa to Ireland.

It’s that it was instituted so hastily — when the roll-out was on the cards for a while — with what appears to be hardly a thought given to people who have existing, paid-for trips planned in a month’s time.

A one-month “grace period” offers some relief for a tiny category of people: Travellers who booked their trips before 10 July can still enter Ireland until 10 August (provided they have proof of their bookings and a valid passport, to state the obvious).

However, those who booked before (or after) 10 July but are only travelling to Ireland after 10 August now need a visa.

And a transit visa is mandatory if you’re just passing through Ireland on your way to another country.

An Irish visa doesn’t cost as much as Schengen visas — a single-entry, short-stay visa will cost R1,200 and multiple-entry visas are R2,000 — but that’s not the point. To lump a new, onerous requirement on travellers — who have already spent a lot on their tickets and probably accommodation — without being able to guarantee a quick turnaround for visa applications is of little comfort.

Cold shoulder


Despite Irish Ambassador Austin Gormley’s assurance that a “warm Irish welcome” awaits travellers, it feels more like a cold shoulder to our country. Ireland, he said, “of course, enjoys very strong [ties] in Africa, including political, economic, people-to-people and of course, sport.” 

Explaining that the new visa requirements were introduced to align with the Schengen area and the UK, he said Ireland would continue to facilitate “legitimate travel” to the country.

Immigration is a hot topic in Ireland. The left-leaning Politico describes parts of Dublin and Cork as being “turned into foul-smelling refugee camps”. These refugees, who escaped war, famine and poverty, view “Ireland as their last-chance saloon to stay in Europe, now that Britain has withdrawn the welcome mat”.

Sharing 500km of a “soft” border with its Northern Ireland neighbour, refugees flooded into the EU through the Irish “back door” to escape Britain’s Rwanda extradition plan, before new UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer acknowledged the plan was “dead and buried”.

European Union law applies to all member states, but three states have negotiated opt-outs from legislation or treaties, so they do not have to participate in certain policy areas. 

Before Brexit, the UK had four opt-outs in place (including the euro). Denmark, which has two opt-outs (including the euro), rapidly retreated on its third exemption — security commitments — after Russia attacked Ukraine. Poland has opted out of the Charter of Fundamental Rights. Ireland, which is not part of the Schengen zone but part of the EU, had two opt-outs (from the area of freedom, security and justice and the Schengen agreement), although Europe’s refugee crisis forced it to announce in June that it would opt in to the EU’s Pact on Migration and Asylum, to tackle this global issue in solidarity with other member states.

This sudden change in visa regulations hasn’t gone down well with South African travellers or travel agents, who have described the lack of notice and immediate implementation as “regrettable”.

Irish consul to South Africa Evan Cunningham says travellers concerned about the timeline of their visa application can contact travelrequest@justice.ie

But it appears the only available appointments through VFS Global are premium and prime slots, costing between £500 and £1,000, which a customer described on Twitter as “pure exploitation after paying the high costs of visas & the minimum monthly wage in SA being less than £200”.

VFS says the appointment system works on a first-come, first-served basis — and it’s the embassies that determine the number of slots.

It’s not about the rugby. But it is a shambles. DM

A previous version of this article incorrectly stated that Ireland is part of the Schengen Zone. Ireland is, in fact, a member of the European Union. We apologise for the error.

Comments (5)

mikesz@teknisk-viking.com Jul 15, 2024, 11:55 AM

Instead of blaming the Irish, we need to do the following: 1. Purge the Home Affairs system of suspicious ID numbers. 2. Enhance our passports and FINALLY make them biometric, other countries in Africa already do this. 3. Do the same with our ID cards and remove that ridiculous old Green ID book. This at least will give the rest of the world some comfort that we in SA are taking corruption and fraud somewhat seriously.

Miss Jellybean Jul 12, 2024, 10:16 AM

Why do we not have reciprocal visa requirements for travellers from countries where we have to get visas? Basically the EU, UK, US & now Ireland require us to have visas but they don't need them to come here. Seems very one sided.

Em Krit Jul 12, 2024, 10:45 AM

We need income from their tourism much more than they need ours, so punitive visa requirements would hurt us more than them. But also, we have very little risk from them entering and country and trying to stay on illegally! I'm personally very unhappy about the new visa requirement but responding with punitive measures unfortunately won't help us.

Trevor Milton Jul 12, 2024, 09:27 AM

Nobody can argue against Irelands right to impose a Visa on any country. They do however have an obligation to assist those who in good faith booked and paid for their travel prior to the announcement. How they manage this process is how they will be judged. Sadly so far they are failing badly. A 30 day waiver does not help those who are about to leave South Africa on their tour in the next week or two or those working and living in a country where Ireland has no representation. Nobody answers the phone at the embassy and their message system is full. They do ask you to email them on a dedicated email address but this solicits a standard automated response that simply refers you to their website and a VFS visa application process. Well that does not help as nobody reads your particular issue! This is far from a "warm Irish welcome" offered! Come on Ireland you can do better? Start by extending the waiver period for those that can show they booked prior to 8th August to maybe 60 or 90 days. This way you can reduce your work load and give the visa process time to settle. If you are concerned that some "crooks" will still enter your country allow at US B1B2 visa and or a Schengen Visa entry. What would be your risk?

richard@cullis.co.za Jul 12, 2024, 12:45 PM

I am one of those that is outside South Africa and this was their response to me: (Cut and paste. not the grimmer mistakes! cut - you will need to you than have to schedule an appointment) Dear Customer, Thank you for contacting the Ireland visa help desk. Please note that each applicant is required to appear in person at the center on the day of your appointment. VFS Pretoria, Johannesburg and Cape Town are the only centres that handle Ireland applications. Kindly note that you need to complete the application form, gather all the supporting documents according to the checklist as per visa type. Additionally, you will need to you than have to schedule an appointment to submit your supporting documents. Applications must be made 8 weeks prior to departure. Kindly refer to the following for visa application process: For further assistance kindly contact the Call Centre on this number: +27124253050. Thank you for contacting The Ireland visa Help Desk. Have a great day ahead.

Rod MacLeod Jul 12, 2024, 08:35 AM

A shambles, Georgina? Are you aware that most countries introduced strict visa controls on SA passports over the last 20 years because our corrupt and shambolic Home Affairs officials issued fraudulent passports to anyone prepared to pay cash for the privilege? The new regime in Botswana is now headed in the same direction as South Africa - corruption and maladministration. Frankly, I'm surprised it took Ireland so long to introduce a visa requirement.

davethomas1002000 Jul 12, 2024, 08:30 AM

But Ireland is not in the Schengen Zone!

Georgina Jul 12, 2024, 12:03 PM

Thanks for pointing out the error, Dave - I've corrected the article!

mikevgelder@hotmail.com Jul 12, 2024, 11:41 AM

Also noticed that. Maybe just an awkward phrasing, but bisappointing detail from DM.