Daily Maverick
Dailymaverick logo

Opinionistas

This is an opinion piece. The views expressed are not that of Daily Maverick.....

Beware the ugly face of eco-fascism rearing its head in the climate justice space

Angelo C Louw
By Angelo C Louw
16 Jul 2024
Facebook
5
Eco-fascism is an ideology blaming the climate crisis on overpopulation, immigration and over-industrialisation. The eco-fascists are referring to us, the black and brown people of the world, who they assume are destroying it with our sex lives.

“Covid-19 is the world’s way of balancing out this overpopulation,” they say. “People should stop having so many babies. There are already too many people in the world, it just cannot handle the strain.”

In my time with the climate justice movement, I’m sometimes left shocked and grossly offended by the ignorance and casual racism displayed by some of my peers in the name of saving the planet.

“Human beings are the problem, we should all die,” sits right there at the top of the list.

Let me explain. They don’t mean all humans when longing for this mass extermination, they mean human beings having babies at a disproportionate rate.

And with a general lack of access to healthcare in the global majority, let alone access to family planning and reproductive health, they are referring to us: the black and brown people of the world who they assume are destroying it with our sex lives. (This adds a whole new dimension to the hypersexualisation of people of colour, but that’s a whole other discussion altogether.)

Eco-fascism


This thinking is so rife within the movement that opinion makers have even coined a term for it: eco-fascism. It is an ideology blaming the climate crisis on overpopulation, immigration and over-industrialisation.

According to Vice, eco-fascists think we could partly remedy these problems through the mass murder of refugees in Western countries. Oh, and by spaying people of colour like dogs, evidently.

The correlation between overpopulation and carbon footprint is horribly misinformed. In fact, believing that people who can barely afford to feed their families are the cause of the overconsumption that is responsible for climate change sounds pretty silly when you say it out loud. In my country, South Africa, more than 50% of the population lives below the $1.90 per person per day (about R34) poverty line. So, we are definitely not the ones to point a finger at.

On the contrary, our culture is not wasteful. Being of both African and Asian descent, I can almost categorically say that frugality is instilled in us – probably because there is never really much to go around in our communities. Eco-friendly practices such as reuse, meat-free meals, and subsistence farming have been a part of our culture long before they became trendy in the West.

Read more: As climate risks amplify state fragility, will Kenya be better prepared when floods hit again?

Who you should be pointing a finger at are those so-called “developed” countries that, despite their excellent family planning facilities and controlled birth rates, contribute the most to the world’s carbon emissions.

In 2015, Oxfam released a study that found that the richest 10% of people worldwide produced half of the planet’s individual-consumption-based fossil fuel emissions, while the poorest 50% of the world’s population – about 3.5 billion people – contributed a mere 10%.

Yes. The reality is that carbon emissions are predominantly caused by, and for the comfort of, the wealthy whiter West; but they affect the poorer, black and brown people of the world at an alarmingly disproportionate rate.

A series of recent reports by the United Nations Environment Programme, Unep, showed time and again that the victims of environmental injustice – from pollution, harmful extraction, and overconsumption – are people of colour, particularly women. One study found, for example, that the differences in gender, social roles and political power in regulating plastic and health standards placed women at high risk of developing cancer and having miscarriages.

Global economy run on devaluation of black lives


As noted by my fellow Fulbright award recipient and climate activist, Dr Alex Lenferna, the global economy is run on the devaluation of black lives and black land, often in the service of predominantly white capital and interests. Lenferna wrote that in the end, environmental injustice is in many ways an extension and continuation of colonial injustice – that is, the exploitation of our land and people to benefit former colonial powers.

The belief that people of colour are inherently to blame for everything wrong in the world is a tired and counterproductive narrative that continues to mislead people by shifting focus from the real problem, and those who are really in the wrong. There is no more room for gaslighting. And, right now, we don’t have the luxury of being anything but honest with ourselves if we are to stop the crisis on our hands.

Only if we are truthful with ourselves can we find real and effective solutions to the climate crisis as well as the environmental injustice faced by the global majority.

We can’t rely on false solutions that encourage genocide and fuel hate – that is far too big a price to pay for your overindulgence. DM

Daily Maverick’s journalism is funded by the contributions of our Maverick Insider members. If you appreciate our work, then join our membership community. Defending Democracy is an everyday effort. Be part of it. Become a Maverick Insider.

Categories:

Tags: