Business, labour and communities accuse government of dragging its feet on income relief after looting

A week after rampant looting and street violence, which has the potential to undermine SA’s economic recovery, dent investor confidence and worsen the already worrying unemployment crisis, the government is yet to mount any income-relief measures for affected businesses and households.

The government was handed a detailed set of income-relief proposals by its business, labour and community partners on Monday at the National Economic Development and Labour Council (Nedlac) — the implementation of which is yet to come to fruition. The partners have met at least three times at Nedlac since last week’s events of anarchy, which President Cyril Ramaphosa has described as an “insurrection” that had “failed”.

Labour stakeholders at Nedlac have accused the government of dragging its feet on implementing income-relief measures for businesses that had their operations looted and damaged, and individuals who are temporarily or permanently jobless as a result. 

“We don’t have the luxury of time. But the government is moving slow on implementing some of the relief measures,” Matthew Parks, the parliamentary coordinator for Cosatu, told Business Maverick after the Nedlac meeting on Monday.

The Nedlac partners want Rampahosa’s Cabinet to approve income-relief measures by the end of the week, which would pave the way for their implementation.

The government, through its representatives, has told Nedlac stakeholders that it is still auditing the full extent and cost of damages to businesses in Gauteng and KwaZulu-Natal — especially small businesses — and affected households. This auditing exercise, once completed, will enable the government to target its relief measures to where they are needed the most.

But the South African Property Owners’ Association (Sapoa), an organisation that represents owners of commercial property including listed and unlisted companies and private individuals, has already counted the preliminary costs of the unrest in Gauteng and KwaZulu-Natal. According to Sapoa, 200 shopping malls have been looted and damaged, approximately 3,000 stores have been looted, 1,400 ATMs have been damaged, and 113 communications infrastructure elements (including cellular network towers) have been damaged. In KwaZulu-Natal alone, 40,000 formal businesses have been affected, putting 150,000 jobs at risk.

Acting Minister in the Presidency Khumbudzo Ntshavheni said during a briefing with journalists on Monday that the government is still working on a “consolidated package”, which includes cash flow assistance for affected small businesses and households.

The government also told Nedlac stakeholders that it is doing a number-crunching exercise, which will include assessing whether the fiscus (or the SA taxpayer) can afford to fund income-relief measures.

Some of the income-relief measures proposed by business, labour, and community partners are similar to those implemented by the government after SA went into a hard lockdown in March 2020. These include:

• The reinstatement of the government’s loan guarantee scheme and a temporary suspension of loan repayments by affected businesses and households. The loan guarantee scheme was introduced in May 2020 and ran until April 2021. It was operated by the government, SA Reserve Bank, and commercial banks to offer loans at favourable interest rates to businesses. The scheme flopped. (Read more here.) 


• The reinstatement of the R350-a-month Covid-19 social grant, which came to an end in April. The grant provides relief to individuals above the age of 18 who are unemployed, do not receive any income or any other social grant. It costs the National Treasury about R2-billion a month for the grant to be administered. 


• The reinstatement of Unemployment Insurance Fund (UIF) payouts to workers who have been temporarily or permanently sent home because of looting and violence. The UIF payout scheme was reinstated on 19 July 2021 as part of income-relief measures during the extension of Level 4 lockdown regulations. Business, labour, and community partners want UIF payouts to be expedited to also accommodate business owners and households affected by the looting and violence.