Dailymaverick logo

South Africa

This article is more than a year old

South Africa

Call to action against Western Cape teacher job cuts, while MEC Maynier says situation is ‘critical’

Community mobilises to fight the axing of 2,407 teaching posts after national Treasury cuts the province’s budget by R3.8bn.
Call to action against Western Cape teacher job cuts, while MEC Maynier says situation is ‘critical’ An attendee at the meeting in Community House, Salt River in Cape Town on Saturday, 7 September. (Photo: Lisakanya Ashley Venna)

A united front against education cuts emerged at Salt River’s Community House on Saturday, 7 September where teachers, parents, learners and union representatives met to resist the Western Cape Government’s plan to cut 2,407 teacher posts by 2025.

The cuts to teaching posts were announced earlier this month by MEC David Maynier

teacher job cuts maynier Western Cape Education MEC David Maynier. (Photo: Gallo Images / Nardus Engelbrecht)



In the announcement, Maynier said that “we are doing everything we can to fight for our teachers, but we are being short-changed by the national government, receiving only 64% of the cost of the nationally negotiated wage agreement, leaving the province to fund the remaining 36%, resulting in a massive budget shortfall of R3.8-billion.”

Read more: ‘The system is going to collapse’ – Union warns Western Cape over plans to slash 2,400 teaching posts

The meeting, which drew more than 40 attendees, was chaired by Abeedah Adams, one of the six people who initiated the movement.

Adams said that “when we got the news of the pending cuts of 2,407 teachers, it was very alarming and we were concerned and we kept looking out to see who is going to respond to this, and we eventually came to the realisation that we need to do something.’’ 

The movement opposing budget cuts has expanded significantly, with its WhatsApp group up to 1,000 members. The group has also initiated a petition which has gained 50,000 signatures to date.

Aliah Chickte, a movement member, said it was hoped the petition would reach 100,000 signatures by the end of the year. The signatures will be submitted during the budget speech next year, as the movement continues to advocate against budget cuts.

Call to action


Community member Brian Ashley emphasised the need for a collective effort to stop budget cuts across essential sectors.

“We have to stop the cuts in education, social security and health. We can’t just focus on education, though it is extremely important, we have to defend our teachers, we have to defend our children’s education – we have to stop the cuts and we can do this by mobilising those in terms of what we do now locally, building structures, to coordinate, to understand, to educate, to understand the nature of the cuts that have been taking place and the impact and where the money can come from.’’

teacher job cuts meeting An attendee at the meeting in Community House, Salt River in Cape Town on Saturday, 7 September. (Photo: Lisakanya Ashley Venna)



Ashley criticised the Democratic Alliance (DA) for its role in the budget cuts claiming that “the DA, which is hiding behind Treasury, now has been the one putting the most pressure on (President Cyril) Ramaphosa to cut budgets, to bring down the wages of public sector workers which are poor.”

Union response


Sibongile Kwazi, Provincial Secretary of the South African Democratic Teachers’ Union (Sadtu) in the Western Cape, said there was a contradiction between the DA’s election manifesto promises and its current actions. 

“The employer of teachers in the province is not the minister of education, but it is the head of education for this province… Our fight needs to be with them in this province, and you will remember that in the manifesto of the DA, they promised to create more jobs, and what they are doing now is the direct opposite because they are cutting the jobs, instead of creating more jobs.”

Kwazi said that “we were the first ones to hear about the cuts and the teachers’ staff establishments. By legislation, that is by law, every year the education department must consult all teacher unions as well as school governing organisations on the budget of posts for the following year. This year, we were told that because of the budget cuts, we are short of R3.8-billion within WCED and with the increases of salaries of teachers for 2024, nationally, that is the Department of Education nationally, only paid 64% of that money.”

Kwezi said Sadtu had already met Cosatu and would convene a stakeholders’ meeting soon.

Learner response


Yonela Zembe, a learner from Manzomthombo Secondary School and a member of Equal Education, voiced her concerns in the meeting.

“The reason that Equal Education has come here is because, without a teacher, there is no learner and without a learner and a teacher, there is no school,” Zembe said.

Zembe expressed surprise at the sudden interest in Equal Education from teachers: “I want to say to my teachers, with you here, you’ve called for Equal Education to come and represent you here today only because it benefits you, but for the past 16 years that Equal Education has been operating, you have never even once attended one of our events… but today, we are here to intertwine with you and show you that we are in this together, so we want you to return that back.”

Multiple speakers suggested follow-up meetings to further discuss the issue, while others called for immediate action.

Maynier’s plea


Citing the R3.8-billion budget shortfall because of national funding cuts, MEC Maynier urged teachers’ unions to cooperate.

In a statement released on Thursday, 5 September, he said “striking will not change the fact that we are being short-changed by the national government”.

“The situation is critical. If we do not take drastic action to cover the massive shortfall, we compromise our ability to pay for our bills, which includes the salaries of teachers.” DM

Comments (7)

seanbozalek53 Sep 9, 2024, 06:06 PM

Slashing 2400 teaching posts cud cause the system to collapse. Maynier claims National government has short changed the W Cape , he is passing the buck , the DA form part of the GNU , why have they not made their case to overturn this decision ? I am afraid they lack the political will power to act.

Maj.knox1@gmail.com Sep 9, 2024, 08:34 PM

This was implemented before the GNU was even became the GNU... every Province is short the billions promised to the civil servent salary increase.

onceoffaddress@gmail.com Sep 9, 2024, 02:30 PM

take money from SAPO (it is a waste of money and the jobs there are fake jobs that don't deliver any value), or, take funds from SASSA (people reciveing that money are just leeching) whereas teachers are doing real work and contributing something of value. Priorities, People!

Maj.knox1@gmail.com Sep 9, 2024, 02:19 PM

Why the huge fuss over the Western Cape, except for the usual obvious reasons..... every Province is doing the same, but that is downplayed, also because of the obvious reasons..... anc ineptitude....

Pieter van de Venter Sep 9, 2024, 11:11 AM

Why should facts stand in the way of a good protest??? Blame the DA is rather rich. Maynier is just the first to announce it or maybe the only one as the other 8 provinces might just either ignore the cut of funding or not tell anybody.

Karl Sittlinger Sep 9, 2024, 10:50 AM

"Ashley criticised the Democratic Alliance (DA) for its role in the budget cuts claiming that “the DA, which is hiding behind Treasury" You simply cannot blame the DA for a national budget cut of that magnitude. This was done before the GNU and is very much the ANCs fault. 300chars DM?

Maj.knox1@gmail.com Sep 9, 2024, 08:41 AM

What the anc politburo giveth, so the anc politburo shall taketh away..

cs0834815071 Sep 9, 2024, 06:18 AM

Dont collect signatures alone. That will not change anything . Start collecting 3.8 billion rand from the western cape school community and the problem will go away During this collection process I am sure you will learn exactly what Maynier is facing. Dont oppose him, join him.