Dailymaverick logo

South Africa

South Africa

‘Crooking’ the books — turning the lens on private sector shenanigans

‘Crooking’ the books — turning the lens on private sector shenanigans
For years the ANC-led South African government’s reputation on the global stage was tainted by corruption. But is South Africa’s private sector — and the global auditing and consulting firms working with it — really any better?

“You see those logos of big companies at career expos… and wonder: What do these companies actually do? Well, lucky for you, we’ve got a handy video to guide you through the jungle that is South Africa’s corporate sector.”

This time on Politically Aweh, South Africa’s wittiest online satirical news show, hilarious host KG Mokgadi gets hot under the collar about private sector corruption, assisted by a “career guidance counsellor” from the “South African Institute of Crony Accountants and other Professionals”. 

Together they break down some of the biggest corporate heists South Africa has ever seen and how they were aided and abetted by the very companies that were meant to spot and stop the rot.

https://youtu.be/US8ayGPa0G8

By the time the house of cards that was Steinhoff finally collapsed, this multinational corporation with more than 40 brands and the poster child for globalised South African success had overstated its profits by $7.4-billion. 

According to the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners,  the longer the duration of fraud committed, the greater the losses: “Only 7% of frauds will last longer than five years, (and the Steinhoff International fraud lasted for) eight years … the longer fraud goes on, the higher the damages that are resulting from that fraud.” 

So how did it go on for so long, for so much, before the stealing came to light?

According to Financial Sector Conduct Authority of South Africa investigator Alex Pascoe, the hype surrounding Steinhoff and its former CEO, Markus Jooste, left many people completely blindsided by the unfolding events. 

“Because of the group’s size, the company was subject to a fragmented audit, and minimal control aided the fraud.” So essentially they were too big to be suspected of out and out theft. 

KG just calls it like it is: “Because it’s white… collar crime, we don’t call it corruption, or stealing, we call it ‘accounting irregularities’ or ‘misappropriation of funds’. For decades, their auditing firm, Deloot, sorry, I mean Deloitte, said everything was cool and normal.”

But everything was not cool and normal. 

The Steinhoff scandal is South Africa’s largest corporate fraud, resulting in more than R250-billion (that’s 250 thousand millions, people) in losses for investors who had entrusted their precious savings to the company through various investment vehicles. 

This includes the Public Investment Corporation, which manages public sector workers’ pension funds. And just like government corruption, there is a lot more ass covering than taking responsibility and making reparations to the ordinary people whose lives were gutted. 

Ironically, in a recent media statement the ANC welcomed the conviction of the former CFO of Steinhoff, Andries “Ben” la Grange and sentencing to “a 10 year imprisonment, with 5 years suspended by the Pretoria Specialised Crimes Court”. 

Improvement


This conviction is an improvement on the disappointing five-year suspended sentence that was handed down last week to Dr Gerhardus Diedricks Burger, another Steinhoff criminal who was charged with insider trading.”

“At least in government there are consequences for corruption… Hey, come on now! The minister will at least get redeployed to Arts and Culture. Or Ambassador to Estonia…” 

What about the auditors, consultants and banks who ignored the red flags or actively enabled the looting? 

Deloitte has made more than R1-billion in reparations, but otherwise is still in business. One big problem is that the same firms are doing the accounting, and the auditing, which is like marking your own homework. We all know how that goes. 

So the Audit Regulator, IRBA, is trying to make it compulsory for companies who are in long-term relationships with their auditors to mix it up every 10 years, even though some auditors and firms are resisting. 

Change may not be certain, but one thing is for sure, government and private sector corruption? Same WhatsApp group. DM

For more from Politically Aweh, subscribe to their YouTube channel, or follow on Instagram, Facebook, TikTok or X.

Categories: