Fact-Check – Did Helen Zille call MK and EFF politicians “dogs”?

In early July, social media went wild when it was reported that DA federal chair Helen Zille had referred to MK and EFF politicians in KwaZulu-Natal as “dogs”.

But did this really happen?

https://www.timeslive.co.za/politics/2024-07-04-many-defend-zilles-kzn-will-not-be-thrown-to-the-dogs-remarks/

The source of the report was a press conference given by Helen Zille in Johannesburg on Tuesday 2 July in response to the deadlock in negotiations around the Gauteng coalition government between the DA and the ANC.

https://youtu.be/Joh4yq2Q9yw

What Zille actually said was:

“We are not going to bring KwaZulu-Natal down if they don’t agree to the document terms in Gauteng. We are not going to do that. We are not irresponsible people. 

“We don’t want to hand KwaZulu-Natal to the MK and EFF. It will be a total disaster for that province…

“We are not going to say the people of KZN can be thrown to the dogs.”

In response, the KZN youth wing of the MK party accused Zille of calling “the people of KZN” dogs.

They said they were sending “warning shots” to Zille as a result.

Many users of platforms like X also piled on, accusing Zille of racism.

Zille responded by terming the issue “manufactured outrage”, and pointing out that being “thrown to the dogs” is a well-known English idiom.

The standard definition of allowing something to “go to the dogs” or be “thrown to the dogs” is to allow something to deteriorate in quality. 

Online etymology sites suggest that the derivation is from around the fifteenth century and referred to spoiled foods being given to dogs.

Helen Zille was not literally referring to MK and EFF politicians as dogs; she was expressing the view that if the DA pulled out of KwaZulu Natal politics, the situation for the people of KZN would worsen. DM

Daily Maverick’s journalism is funded by the contributions of our Maverick Insider members. If you appreciate our work, then join our membership community. Defending Democracy is an everyday effort. Be part of it. Become a Maverick Insider.