Dailymaverick logo

Business Maverick

This article is more than a year old

Business Maverick

Gwede Mantashe considers application to exclude Nelson Mandela Bay from fuel price drop

Mineral Resources and Energy Minister Gwede Mantashe is considering an application that will see Nelson Mandela Bay zoned as an ‘inland’ area because fuel wholesalers can no longer use the Port Elizabeth Harbour to drop off fuel for road tankers. If successful, the metro and surrounding towns will lose out on a significant cut in the price of petrol in October.
Gwede Mantashe considers application to exclude Nelson Mandela Bay from fuel price drop

Delays by Transnet to fix the fuel gantry in the Port Elizabeth harbour will cost motorists in the Nelson Mandela Bay region dearly from next month as they will not receive the bulk of a significant drop in the price of fuel – that is if the Minister of Mineral Resources and Energy, Gwede Mantashe, approves an application by the Liquid Fuel Wholesalers Association.

The Department confirmed this week that an application to have Nelson Mandela Bay and surrounding towns rezoned as an “inland” region, despite its two harbours, is before Mantashe for consideration.

In June 2024, a vessel carrying LPG gas collided with the Tanker Berth at the Port Elizabeth Harbour, rendering it unusable.

Transnet triggered an emergency procurement process for experts to assess the damage, but estimates show that the damage is likely to be fixed only early next year.

The plan was to award the tender by 5 September 2024, and a comment from Transnet on the repair progress is awaited.

The full answer from the department to questions from Daily Maverick about the “rezoning” of Nelson Mandela Bay reads: “The Minister is considering the request after consultation with the fuel industry associations. All the affected Magisterial District Zones will change once the Minister has taken a decision on the request.”

Read more: Harbour debacle — Nelson Mandela Bay fuel wholesalers ask minister for exemption from price drop

The application is based on the extra travel costs borne by fuel wholesalers as they now have to fetch fuel at the East London Harbour and transport it to Nelson Mandela Bay by road.

The argument put forward to the minister is that fuel wholesalers, transporters and retailers cannot be expected to operate in a blatantly unfair business environment, that they can not cover the increased costs and that a rezoning increase will be a “small fraction” of the price reduction.

It is understood that if approved, this “rezoning” price regime will remain in place until Transnet has repaired the fuel gantry and fuel can again be imported at the Port Elizabeth Harbour.

Commenting on this development, the Democratic Alliance’s James Lorimer asked: “What are they thinking? There is no way the people of Nelson Mandela Bay should suffer financially for mistakes made in the harbour. There is also no way in good conscience that Mantashe can agree to put the profits of fuel wholesalers ahead of the interests of residents of an entire city.”

On Thursday, the Automobile Association said South African motorists could expect to save more at the pumps in October when fuel prices were adjusted next week. 

Current unaudited data from the Central Energy Fund (CEF) indicate significant reductions to fuel prices across the board, making this the fifth consecutive decrease this year.

“According to the CEF’s figures, ULP95 petrol is expected to be lower by around R1.13/litre while ULP93 is set for a drop of around R1.05/l. Diesel is expected to drop between R1.12/l and R1.10/l while illuminating paraffin will drop by around R1.08/l.”

Read more: Consumer Relief — AA projects big fuel price cuts at the pump in October for fifth month on the trot

If Nelson Mandela Bay is rezoned, motorists will pay an extra 30 cents per litre of petrol, which will erode the gains from a drop in the price of petrol. Inland prices for diesel, paraffin and liquified gas are also higher.

“Although we are expecting fuel to be cheaper in October, we remain committed to advocating for a sustainable solution to mitigating high fuel costs and believe it is still necessary. The AA again calls on the government to urgently initiate a transparent review of the fuel price and, critically, to involve all role players who have a stake in fuel pricing,” the AA said in a statement on Thursday.

The official fuel pricing announcement for October by the Department of Mineral and Petroleum Resources (DMPR) is expected on Monday, 30 September, ahead of the adjustment at midnight next Wednesday, 2 October. DM

Comments (6)

David McCormick Sep 28, 2024, 03:23 PM

Is Mossel Bay not suitable? Surely this port was used to transport fuel before Mossgas was shut down by PetroSA? Much closer to Nelson Mandela Bay than East London. (Is Port Elizabeth Harbour not Gqeberha Harbour now? )

Greeff Kotzé Sep 28, 2024, 04:09 PM

The National Ports Authority seems to not care for the new name, still referring to "Port of Port Elizabeth" in all of its current documentation, including the FY 2024-25 Tariff Book. I'd submit that the "Port of" part has now become redundant.

Greeff Kotzé Sep 28, 2024, 02:17 PM

It should be noted that none of this would be necessary if construction of the planned liquid bulk terminal at Nqura (despite having already commenced) had not been cancelled in 2020 due to "insufficient customer commitment". The customers being the petroleum refiners & distributors in this case.

Indeed Jhb Sep 28, 2024, 05:43 PM

Wonder where that 'saving' went - could have been used here. Transnet should pay up for their mistakes - their pilot

Richard Robinson Sep 28, 2024, 08:36 AM

In "June 2024, a vessel carrying LPG gas collided with the Tanker Berth at the Port Elizabeth Harbour, rendering it unusable." Was a competent Transnet harbour pilot operating the vessel at the time?

Greeff Kotzé Sep 28, 2024, 02:10 PM

According to Estelle's previous article, "In June 2024, a fuel tanker was piloted into Port Elizabeth Harbour when huge swells occurred. Even though it was under pilotage, it crashed into a crucial bunker normally used to transfer fuel to tanker trucks for distribution to petrol stations."

Ian Gwilt Sep 28, 2024, 08:34 AM

who was in charge of the LPG Tanker Accident happened in April, no repair yet started ?

Rodshep80@gmail.com Sep 28, 2024, 07:48 AM

You get the government that you vote or don't vote for. The people pay for every mistake made by an incompetent government. What happened to the insurance that should have covered incidents like this. 25% of a year to start a repair of such great importance. The mind boggles.

Gavin Hillyard Sep 28, 2024, 07:03 AM

I don’t believe that the fuel wholesalers should have to absorb the additional transport costs for Transnet inefficiency. Sadly PE residents will have to cough up. The result of voting (yet again) for the wrong party. But I am confident that the penny will eventually drop.