Daily Maverick
Dailymaverick logo

Sport

Sport, Maverick News

IOC issues proposals for Russian athletes’ return to competitions — but few are happy

IOC issues proposals for Russian athletes’ return to competitions — but few are happy
Viktoriia Meshkova of Russia during the Sport Climbing Women's Combined Qualification on day twelve of the Tokyo 2020 Olympic Games at Aomi Urban Sports Park on 4 August, 2021 in Tokyo, Japan. (Photo: Tsuyoshi Ueda)
Karolos Grohmann
By Karolos Grohmann
29 Mar 2023
Facebook
1
The International Olympic Committee’s decision to open the door for a return by Russian and Belarusian athletes has met with criticism from both sides of the divide.

The International Olympic Committee (IOC) this week issued recommendations for the gradual return to international competitions for Russian and Belarusian athletes as neutrals.

President Thomas Bach said their participation “works” despite the war in Ukraine.

The IOC Executive Board's recommendations concern the return of those athletes to international competitions but not the 2024 Paris Olympics where a separate decision will be taken at a later date.

However, the recommendations triggered angry reactions from countries opposed to Russian and Belarusian participation as well as from Russia, whose Olympic Committee chief, called them “absolutely unacceptable.”

Bach told a news conference after the IOC meeting: “Sports organisations must have the sole responsibility to decide which athletes can take part in international competitions based on their sporting merits and not on political grounds or because of their passports.”

He said the recommendations for events organisers and sports federations to follow included that Russian and Belarusian athletes can only compete as neutrals, with no flag or anthem.

They cannot take part in team events and must have a proven drugs testing record, while athletes who support the war or are contracted to their countries' military or national security agency are excluded.

These recommendations do not include the 2024 Olympics and the potential participation of Russia and Belarus, Bach said.

“The IOC will take this decision at the appropriate time at its full discretion, without being bound by results of previous Olympic qualifiers,” Bach said. He did not say when the IOC would take that decision.

The IOC had sanctioned Russia and Belarus after the February 2022 invasion of Ukraine, which Moscow calls a ‘special military operation’, but it is now eager to see athletes come back across all sports and have a chance to qualify for the Paris Games. 

It has set out a pathway for these competitors to earn Olympic slots through Asian qualifying but has faced headwinds, with Ukraine threatening to boycott next year's Olympics should they compete there, even as neutrals.

‘Day of shame’


Poland, a neighbour to Ukraine, reacted angrily to the IOC’s recommendations, calling it a “day of shame” for the Olympic body.

“What happened that was so positive from the Russian side that their athletes should take part in competitions,” Polish Deputy Foreign Minister Piotr Wawrzyk tweeted.

“After Bucha, Irpin, Hostomel! After daily bombing of civilian targets! It's a day of shame for the IOC!”

Czech Foreign Minister Jan Lipavsky said Russia had no place in the Olympics. “I am disappointed by the IOC recommendations,” Lipavsky wrote on Twitter. “We must not close our eyes to reality. Russian sport is centrally managed by the Kremlin. The Russian regime does not know what fair play is.

“It’s athletes do not belong in the Olympic Games. We will continue to deal with this issue, including with the expert group (Czech Olympic Committee).”

Tatiana Kashirina, Russian athletes Tatiana Kashirina of Russia competes in the women's +87kg weightlifting on day two of the Ready Steady Tokyo - Weightlifting, Tokyo 2020 Olympic Games test event at the Tokyo International Forum on 7 July, 2019 in Tokyo, Japan. (Photo: Toru Hanai/Getty Images)


Participation works


Bach had earlier told the IOC Executive Board that Russian and Belarusian athletes were already competing daily in many sports without facing problems.

“Participation of athletes with Russian and Belarusian passports in international competitions works,” Bach told the board at the start of the meeting at the IOC headquarters in Lausanne.

“We see this almost every day in a number of sports, most prominently in tennis but also in cycling, in some table tennis competitions.

“In none of these competitions security incidents have been happening.”

World Athletics, the biggest Olympic crowd-puller, last week decided to keep Russians and Belarusians banned from all of their events for the foreseeable future due to the Ukraine war, going against the IOC.

A dozen countries boycotted this month’s women’s world boxing championships in protest at the presence of Russians and Belarusians at the event.

More than 300 fencers wrote to Bach to ask the IOC to reconsider allowing them back, calling it a “catastrophic error” should Russia and Belarus return.

Germany’s elite athletes’ grouping Athleten Deutschland on Tuesday also pitched in, calling on the IOC to ban them completely for the duration of the war.

Bach said politics could not be part of sports competitions and athletes should not be punished for their passports.

“We will not be able to come up with a solution which pleases everyone. With this we may have to live.”

Saadat Dalgatova Saadat Dalgatova of Team Russia, left, exchanges punches with Baison Manikon of Team Thailand during their women's welterweight 69-kg boxing match at the Tokyo 2020 Olympics 24 July, 2021 in Tokyo, Japan. (Photo: Frank Franklin II - Pool/Getty Images)


‘Unacceptable’: Russian Olympic head


The head of Russia's Olympic Committee denounced the IOC’s criteria as “unacceptable”.

Stanislav Pozdnyakov, president of the Russian Olympic Committee, told a news conference that he opposed any notion of Russian and Belarusian athletes competing as neutrals with no use of flags or anthems allowed.

He also denounced the imposition of additional anti-doping procedures for Russian competitors — a measure linked to previous doping scandals.

“The parameters as announced are absolutely unacceptable. This is discrimination on the basis of nationality, as repeatedly noted by international human rights specialists...,” Pozdnyakov told a news conference, a video clip of which was posted on his Telegram account.

“Neutral status is a violation of human rights... We believe the proposed conditions to be groundless, void of legal basis and excessive.

“We categorically disagree with conducting additional anti-doping procedures as regards Russian athletes.”

The IOC decision, he said, amounted to “an acknowledgment of their error” when the ban on Russian and Belarusian athletes was introduced days after Russian troops moved into Ukraine.

The IOC, now keen to allow Russian and Belarusian athletes to come back across all sports, has set out a pathway for these competitors to earn Olympic slots through Asian qualifying.

Ukraine has spearheaded a campaign to boycott the Paris Olympic Games should they compete, even as neutrals. Reuters/DM

Viktoriia Meshkova, Russian athletes Viktoriia Meshkova of Russia during the Sport Climbing Women's Combined Qualification on day twelve of the Tokyo 2020 Olympic Games at Aomi Urban Sports Park on 4 August, 2021 in Tokyo, Japan. (Photo: Tsuyoshi Ueda)

Categories:

Tags: