Daily Maverick
Dailymaverick logo

World

World, Maverick Citizen, Op-eds

Israel’s use of starvation as a weapon of war in Gaza

Israel’s use of starvation as a weapon of war in Gaza
Displaced Palestinians from the Gaza Strip queue for drinking water in a temporary camp provided by the United Nations Development Program for displaced Palestinians who lost their homes in Israeli raids, in Khan Yunis, 19 November 2023. More than 12,000 Palestinians and at least 1,200 Israelis have been killed, according to the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) and the Palestinian health authority, since Hamas militants launched an attack against Israel from the Gaza Strip on 07 October, and the Israeli operations in Gaza and the West Bank which followed it. (Photo: EPA-EFE / HAITHAM IMAD)
Stephen Devereux, Julian May and Carla Bernardo
By Stephen Devereux, Julian May and Carla Bernardo
10 Jan 2024
Facebook
8
The Israeli regime’s cutting off and restriction of food and water in its war on Gaza has a hauntingly long history and the implications will be felt for generations to come.

A number of accusations of violations of international humanitarian law have been levelled against the Israeli government over the past three months, including collective punishment, the execution of surrendered Palestinians, the mass murder and detainment of children, the murder of at least 110 journalists and more than 320 healthcare workers, attacks on refugee camps, hospitals, schools, universities and places of worship, and the use of white phosphorus in areas with high population densities. Now, the use of starvation as a weapon of war must be added to this list. These charges will be heard by the International Court of Justice (ICJ) at The Hague on 11 and 12 January 2024.

On 29 December 2023, South Africa lodged an application with the ICJ that accuses the State of Israel of breaching the 1948 Genocide Convention, inter alia by “the starvation of civilians as a method of warfare” (paragraph 2) and “failure to provide or ensure essential food… for the besieged and blockaded Palestinian people, which has pushed them to the brink of famine” (paragraph 4). Genocide refers to acts committed in order “to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group”, including “deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part”. In the context of the deliberately created ongoing food crisis in Gaza, the application mentions “food” 79 times, “hunger” 30 times, “starvation” 20 times, and “famine” five times. Specific acts of genocide identified in the application include “causing widespread hunger, dehydration and starvation to besieged Palestinians in Gaza” (paragraph 114(4)). Further, the convention provides that “direct and public incitement to commit genocide” is a crime in its own right.

Gaza starvation Palestinians line up for free food provided by a Palestinian youth group for displaced people in the Khan Younis refugee camp on 9 January 2024. (Photo: EPA-EFE / Haitham Imad)



Fewer than three months earlier, on 7 October 2023, Palestinian armed groups had launched an attack, targeting Israeli military installations and capturing military and civilian hostages, with a reported civilian death toll of 695 Israelis and 71 foreigners (the Hamas' attack's total death toll was 1,139 - Ed). In response, Israeli defence minister Yoav Gallant announced a complete and shockingly disproportionate siege on Gaza, cutting off essential supplies such as food, water, electricity and cooking gas.

Due to Israel’s refusal to allow adequate humanitarian supplies into Gaza, only about 10% of the food the besieged residents need has been trucked in, according to the United Nations (UN). By mid-November, the World Food Programme was already warning that “people are facing the immediate possibility of starvation”. By 10 December, it announced that “half of Gaza’s population” (1.2 million people) were starving.
Since the Israeli occupation began in 1948, the Palestinian food system has been under assault.

As noted by Tufts University’s Tom Dannenbaum, this is “an abnormally clear-cut instance of starving civilians as a means of war, an unambiguous violation of human rights”.

This is compounded by tactics that target Gaza’s water supply, since safe water is a critical component of nutrition security. Despite Israel’s claim that it had resumed water supply to Gaza on 15 October, a number of sources report a polluted or only intermittent supply. Chemicals emanating from weapons used will or have already entered the water supply, and, more recently, Israel stated its plans to pump seawater into underground tunnels, which would have dire consequences for the already crumbling water infrastructure.

Starvation is one of the most barbaric strategies used to wage war. It is wielded to kill slowly, to crush emotionally, and ultimately to obliterate. Limiting people’s access to food and water, and allowing them to teeter on the brink of starvation and famine, ensures dire and irreversible consequences that will endure for generations.

Spent shells litter the ground at the Erez crossing 9 January 2024. It is the only crossing for people between Israel and the Gaza Strip. More than 22,800 Palestinians and at least 1,300 Israelis have been killed, according to the Palestinian Health Ministry and the Israel Defence Forces, since Hamas militants launched an attack against Israel from the Gaza Strip on 7 October 2023, and the Israeli operations in Gaza and the West Bank that followed it. (Photo: EPA-EFE / Atef Safadi)



A Palestinian boy passes a destroyed house following an Israeli air strike in Deir Al Balah town, southern Gaza Strip, on 7 January 2024. (Photo: EPA-EFE / Mohammed Saber)


A haunting history


Before this latest siege, 80% of the population of Gaza already relied on humanitarian aid as their main source of food and nutrition. Now, as bakeries, community kitchens and food markets are bombed, taps run dry, crops are destroyed and access to international food aid is denied, we are haunted by memories of hunger being used as a weapon of war.

More than 2,000 years ago, Sun Tzu wrote in The Art of War of the interconnectedness of war and food. Julius Caesar is believed to have used starvation as a weapon of war. In South Africa, Shaka used “scorched earth” tactics in his military campaigns, as did the British during the South African War.

During World War 2, Nazi Germany carried out “Der Hungerplan”. By blockading cities such as Leningrad, inhabitants were subjected to prolonged starvation, resulting in the deaths of at least one million civilians. In the Jewish ghettos in Poland, the Nazis controlled and rationed access to food at below-subsistence levels. The Nazi governor in occupied Poland wrote, “that we sentence 1.2 million Jews to die of hunger should be noted only marginally”.

Also in World War 2, German occupying forces blockaded part of the Netherlands for several months in 1944, prohibiting all movements of food and directly causing thousands of deaths by starvation during the Dutch Hunger Winter.

While the famine in Ethiopia in the 1980s was triggered by drought and harvest failure, it took place during a civil war during which trade was restricted, markets in Tigray were bombed, and humanitarian access to affected areas was denied. More than half a million people died.

A 2021 report titled “Starvation Makers: The use of starvation by warring parties in Yemen” documents systematic violations of the right to food since the war began in 2015, including air strikes that targeted farms and irrigation infrastructure, fishing boats and water facilities, as well as restrictions on humanitarian relief that denied access to food and water to starving civilians. Disruptions to food systems and health services have had devastating impacts on food and nutrition security. By 2020, the UN estimated that 131,000 out of 233,000 deaths during the ongoing war in Yemen were due to “indirect causes such as lack of food”.

Residents of the Al Nuseirat and Al Bureij refugee camps evacuate during Israeli military operations in the Gaza Strip on 4 January 2024. Since the 7 October Hamas attacks, up to 1.9 million people, or more than 85% of the population, have been displaced throughout the Gaza Strip, some more than once, according to the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East. (Photo: EPA-EFE / Mohammed Saber)



A Palestinian holds the body of a young relative and cries, during his funeral at Khan Younis in the southern Gaza Strip on 22 November 2023. (Photo: EPA-EFE / Mohammed Saber)


Food crimes in Palestine


Since the Israeli occupation began in 1948, the Palestinian food system has been under assault. In addition to restrictions on marking and mobility, the destruction of crops has been a frequently used and widely criticised method of warfare by the Israeli government.

Olive groves, central to Palestinian livelihoods and culture, have been destroyed by Israeli forces, both in times of conflict and in relative peace. In parts of Gaza such as Khan Younis, farmers require passes to enter and tend to their land. 
Where there is not immediate death and destruction by bombs and bullets, the deliberate use of hunger as a weapon of war is etched into the fabric of affected communities.

Imports and exports are also strictly controlled by the Israeli regime, through the enforcement of a list of banned or restricted items, including dried fruits, coriander, jam and chocolate. Agricultural essentials such as fertilisers are hard to come by, having been deemed a potential ingredient for bomb-making.

In 2019, the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs noted that the expansion of Gaza’s fishing limits by Israel was a positive development, but remained well below the nautical miles that were agreed at the 1993 Oslo Accords, which were therefore violated. As recently as August 2023, the fishing community in Gaza staged a sit-in to protest against the ongoing arrests of fisherfolk, seizure of boats and being “constantly chased, harassed, intimidated and even killed by Israeli forces”. Less than a month later, Israel closed Kerem Shalom, the main commercial crossing in Gaza, a further blow to fisherfolk and an already ailing economy.

The current conflict continues this pattern: During the harvest season in October and November 2023, many Palestinian farmers could not tend to their farms and livestock. Constant bombardment displaced farming families, cutting off their financial lifeline and main source of food. According to reports in early November, nearly 20 Palestinian farmers near Khan Younis had been killed.

Gaza starvation Health staff at the Emirates Crescent Hospital in Rafah in southern Gaza prepare premature babies for transfer to Egypt after they were evacuated from Gaza's Al-Shifa hospital on 20 November 2023. According to the Palestinian Red Crescent, 28 premature infants were transferred on 20 November from the Emirati Hospital to the Rafah Crossing, in coordination with the World Health Organization and the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs. The Egyptian ministry of health said the infants would be transferred to receive medical treatment at hospitals in Arish and Cairo. (Photo: EPA-EFE / Haitham Imad)


Slow, long-lasting violence


In 2003, the UN Special Rapporteur on the Right to Food found a “terrible situation of malnutrition” in the Occupied Palestinian Territories, and concluded that, “although the Government of Israel, as the Occupying Power in the Territories, has the legal obligation under international law to ensure the right to food of the civilian Palestinian population, it is failing to meet this responsibility”. Three years later, Dov Weisglass, an adviser to then prime minister Ehud Olmert, declared that, “the idea is to put the Palestinians on a diet, but not to make them die of hunger”.

Throughout the 75-year occupation, international bodies and human rights watchdogs, among others including the Israeli press, have voiced concern about the Israeli regime’s use of hunger as a weapon. In 2018, the UN Children’s Fund (Unicef) reported an urgent need for strategic action to address child and maternal malnutrition in Gaza.

The urgency of this strategic action is grounded in the widely documented, irreversible impact of malnourishment on a child’s health and development. Children younger than five years and unborn children are particularly at risk, and the nutritional shock of the current hunger in Gaza can permanently constrain their physical and cognitive development. The low birth weights that are likely to result from maternal malnutrition will also increase the risk of infant mortality or disability. Polluted water supplies, the collapse of solid waste removal systems and poor sanitation increase the risk of child diarrhoea, further heightening the risk of chronic malnutrition.

Read more in Daily Maverick: Israel-Palestine War

The implications of weaponising starvation extend beyond immediate suffering and long-term malnutrition. Where there is not immediate death and destruction by bombs and bullets, the deliberate use of hunger as a weapon of war is etched into the fabric of affected communities, resulting in a lifetime of trauma and undermining the prospects for peace and reconciliation, possibly for generations.

Children hold placards and a toy baby covered in mock blood during a protest against child deaths in Palestine, to mark World Children's Day, in Istanbul, Turkey, on 20 November 2023. (Photo: EPA-EFE / Erdem Sahin)



Displaced Palestinians from the Gaza Strip queue on 19 November 2023 for drinking water in a temporary camp in Khan Younis provided by the United Nations Development Programme for those who lost their homes in Israeli raids. (Photo: EPA-EFE / Haitham Imad)


Call to action


One of the most concerning aspects of Israel’s indiscriminate bombing of the people of Gaza is the role of its allies, especially the US, in endorsing and enabling this attack. The inability of the UN Security Council (UNSC) to uphold its humanitarian mandate was thrown into sharp focus when the US used its veto to prevent condemnation of Israel and protect civilian lives in Gaza, by calling for a ceasefire. Citizens across the world should demand an overhaul of the UNSC and its outdated and paralysing voting rules.

The right to adequate food is protected by the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, which has been signed and ratified by 171 countries, including Israel. The intentional starvation of civilians is listed as a war crime in the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court. The Israeli government should be investigated for war crimes in Gaza, and perpetrators should be prosecuted, as should those who have advocated the use of starvation. The South African government’s application to the ICJ, currently supported only by Turkey, Jordan, Malaysia and Bolivia, should be supported by other governments and by international agencies that are concerned with human rights, especially the rights of children to adequate nutrition.

If the permanent effects of chronic malnutrition are to be avoided, humanitarian assistance for Gaza is required at a large scale, immediately and without interference by the Israel Defense Forces. The low levels of child malnutrition following the siege of Sarajevo in the early 1990s were a result of favourable food security conditions prior to the conflict, and the huge international response in terms of food aid. The first does not apply in Gaza, and the second is not yet forthcoming, making the need for food aid to Gaza all the more urgent.

Finally, a stronger response is needed from the university sector. Whatever our nationality, ethnicity, religion or politics, academics and academic institutions should unite to condemn violations of international law, wherever they occur and whoever perpetrates them. Rarely has the cliché been more apposite: This is not about politics, it is about our common humanity. DM

Professor Stephen Devereux is a development economist working on food security, famine, rural livelihoods, social protection and poverty reduction issues. His research experience has been mainly in eastern and southern Africa. He works at the Institute of Development Studies at the University of Sussex, UK, where he is co-director of the Centre for Social Protection. He holds the NRF-Newton Fund (SA-UK) Research Chair in Social Protection for Food Security, affiliated to the DSI-NRF Centre of Excellence in Food Security and the Institute for Social Development at the University of the Western Cape, South Africa.

Julian May is the director of the DSI-NRF Centre of Excellence in Food Security (CoE-FS), which is hosted by the University of the Western Cape and co-hosted by the University of Pretoria. He holds the Unesco Chair in Science and Education for African Food Systems. He has worked on options for poverty reduction including land reform, social grants, information technology and urban agriculture in Africa and in the Indian Ocean Islands. He has also worked on the development and use of systems for monitoring the impact of policy using official statistics, impact assessment and action research. His current research focuses on food security, childhood deprivation and malnutrition. He currently serves on the National Planning Commission and the Council of the Academy of Science of South Africa (ASSAf). He writes in his personal capacity.

Carla Bernardo is the communication and engagement manager at the DSI-NRF Centre of Excellence in Food Security (CoE-FS), which is hosted by the University of the Western Cape and co-hosted by the University of Pretoria. She is the project lead of the Infant and Young Child Feeding Advocacy Project housed within the CoE-FS, and is completing her master’s in political communication at the University of Cape Town.

Categories:

Tags: