Daily Maverick
Dailymaverick logo

South Africa

South Africa, Our Burning Planet

Keen to save rhinos? Focus on their rear ends – not their horns – says veteran conservationist

Keen to save rhinos? Focus on their rear ends – not their horns – says veteran conservationist
Situated on the border with Botswana close to the Kalahari Desert, Madike Game Reserve has become the fifth-largest game park in South Africa, offering visitors a Big 5 safari experience over 750km². Magome directs Madikwe Futures Company (MFC), whichraises funds to maintain the reserve from tourism and lodges. (Photo: courtesy of Flowcom / Wikimedia Commons)
Fred Kockott and Matthew Hattingh
By Fred Kockott and Matthew Hattingh
19 Sep 2023
Facebook
1
Amid the increasingly bloody poaching conflict, a more nurturing approach is required to further rhino conservation, says a former head of conservation at SA National Parks.

A name change as a child gave Hector Magome the steel to face life’s battles on his journey to become a leading rhino conservationist.

When the going gets tough, 62-year-old Magome likes to remember his mom, and how, when he was a boy of seven, she gave him a new name.

“She sat me down, touched both shoulders and said: ‘From today you are Hector. Don’t let anyone call you by your old name’.”

Hector, of course, recalls the mythical Greek hero of the Trojan War, a warrior revered for his bravery and honour. The name means “steadfast” or “holdfast”.

Magome describes his mother – who, as it happened, loathed her own name, Lettie – as both “an ordinary maid in Johannesburg during South Africa’s apartheid era” and a “fierce matriarch”.

She was a woman feared and respected by the family, including her parents.

“She had that aura of authority and the wisdom to know the power of a name,” says Magome. 

“My mother went on to tell me that I was destined for great things… She died two years later, but those words have stuck in my head. They have always helped me to take on many of life’s battles.”

And for Magome, there have been battles aplenty. 

The former head of conservation at SA National Parks (SANParks) has endured the boardroom kind, which led to his ousting on “spurious grounds”, faced up to the fight against rhino poaching, and overcame poverty in his own struggle to make it in the world.

Wide approach


On rhinos and their preservation, Magome believes a wider approach is needed and he will be explaining this at the 12th Oppenheimer Research Conference in Midrand from 4 to 6 October.

The annual conference has grown since 2010 to become an important event on the global academic calendar, showcasing innovative research in the environmental and natural sciences.

Magome, one of the conference’s key presenters, will reflect on a lifetime’s work on the frontline of protected area management, the surge in rhino poaching and wildlife trafficking over the past decade, and how state and private sector partnerships can combat wildlife crime.

save rhinos magome It’s time for fortitude, will and savvy decision-making to secure a safe future for Africa’s rhinoceros, says Hector Magome. (Photo: Miya Thula Photography / September 2023)



Magome shares the vision of the Species Survival Commission of the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) that wild African rhinos will thrive across the continent – if given the space and protection to do so.

He is encouraged by the latest statistics from the IUCN’s African Rhino Specialist Group (AfRSG) showing that rhino poaching abated within most African range states in 2022.

According to the AfRSG, the overall poaching rate on the continent is now below the 3.5% threshold above which populations will decline.

 

“And let’s not forget,” says Magome, “that all the white rhinos we have in South Africa today grew from fewer than 100 rhinos in the 1950s.”

At the CITES 19th Conference of the Parties (COP19) in Panama last year, the AfRSG reported that by the end of 2021, there were more than 15,024 rhinos (2,056 black rhinos and 12,968 white rhinos) in South Africa, making up 68% of the total of Africa’s free-roaming rhino population, estimated at 22,137.

Rhino populations have since gone up by more than 5%, says the AfRSG in a soon-to-be-released report. 

Even amid the devastating poaching scourge, the AfRSG predicts that rhino populations will continue to increase in the various range states across Africa, in particular Namibia, Kenya, Mozambique, Botswana, Tanzania, Malawi, South Africa, and possibly Zimbabwe and Uganda.

But in South Africa, the poaching challenge has proven difficult to solve, says Magome.

When Magome joined SANParks in 1996, there were about 10,000 white rhinos in the Kruger National Park. Today there are barely 2,000. 

 

Dismayed

Magome is dismayed by the failure of the state to protect rhinos in national parks, making them an easy target for poachers.

save rhinos An inquisitive white rhino – viewed through a camera lens, rather than the sights of a gun. (Photo: Jacques Briam)



“All poachers know that the will to protect them is low,” says Magome. This is to be expected when “our law enforcement officers can’t even protect women and children”.

And he is particularly concerned about how vulnerable white rhinos are to poaching.

Unlike its cousin, the black rhino, which is aggressive and dangerous, white rhinos are “sitting ducks for bullets”, says Magome.

 

Bumbling giants 


“They are bumbling giants that even ardent big game hunters should find repugnant to kill," says Magome. 

“They tame quickly, live in open areas, and do not run away (from people), so are easy pickings for poachers.”

save rhinos White rhinos prefer herds which makes them easy targets for poachers. (Photo: Jacques Briam / Wild About The Wild)


Relocation drive 


Faced with the poaching onslaught that was decimating white rhino populations in Kruger when he joined SANParks, Magome began moving many to private game reserves more capable of protecting them.

“You don’t fortify your house or property to fight a hurricane, you evacuate your valuables… The only solution was to move many rhinos to safer areas — a salvage operation,” says Magome.

By 2014, Magome had overseen the relocation of more than 1,500 Kruger white rhinos to private game farms where they served as breeding stock.

Then, amid plans to move an additional 250 rhinos out of Kruger, “puffed-up chameleon egos took over”, says Magome.

“I was pushed out on spurious allegations of not having the authority to sell the 250 white rhinos… The SANParks board later withdrew the charges, paid me out and asked me to leave.”

He moved on from SANParks, undaunted by media reports claiming he had acted improperly in overseeing the deal.

Rhino havens


“At the end of the day, I was proud of the role I played in helping establish rhino breeding programmes on private game reserves,” he says. 

“They have become an increasingly critical haven for the species, and today support the largest number of white rhinos on the continent.”

Today, private game farms and communal lands conserve more than 50% of Africa’s rhino population. 

Magome says the sale of these rhinos had also helped SANParks buy up farming land to increase the size of national parks to make them ecologically viable. 

“Over a million hectares were added to SANParks. That was easy. Commercial farmers are businessmen who sold land when money offers were good.”

Controlled hunting


On concerns that some private game farms that bought Kruger’s rhinos were involved in the sports hunting industry, Magome, and the AfRSG, note that there are more black and white rhinos today in countries that allow hunting and controlled recreational hunting than in countries that don’t. 

Although Magome is not an avid fan of big game hunting –  “I would never want to hunt rhino, elephant or lion” – he says professional hunting does contribute significantly to conservation.

Without this revenue source, private rhino farmers and game reserves would lack the financial incentive to keep wild animals, says Magome.

He said this had already happened in the case of the largest white rhino farmer, John Hume. 

“He recently sold about 2,000 rhinos to retire from rhino conservation.”

Life journey


At the time Magome left SANParks, it had already been quite a journey for the boy from Bapong – “a village between Brits and Rustenburg, in the North West Province, where the Marikana Massacre took place”.

Magome describes his childhood, as one of 10 siblings, as having been tough.

The family survived on a state pension from his grandparents and “a penny here and a pound there” earned by his grandparents working for others in the village.

“I was the only boy among the children. As a result, I was raised to do all the things that girls could do. That made me independent by the age of 12, and I was soon taking on part-time jobs after school, including garden work or picking crops for neighbouring white farmers.

“After I matriculated in 1981, I worked for a year to save enough money for first-year studies in BSc (Education) at the former University of Bophuthatswana.”

Diligence


“I knew that I was good enough to secure a bursary to complete my studies,” says Magome.

He says his diligence ultimately attracted the attention of biology professor Michael Parr, who encouraged him to study wildlife and nature conservation.

“After getting my degree, Prof Parr designed a full-time BSc Honours programme for me. Assisted by three mentors, I conducted research into grasses and the feeding habits of the white rhinoceros. Those field trips instilled in me an undying love for nature,” says Magome.

Mentors 


These role models and other mentors helped Magome complete two, overlapping MSc degrees. One was at Wits University, studying the habitat selection and feeding behaviour of the sable antelope in Pilanesberg. The other was an MSc in Wildlife Biology at Colorado State University in America, financed by a USAID Equal Opportunity Study Grant.

“Armed with two MSc degrees, I earned myself the unfortunate title of being called the first black South African to become a wildlife ecologist in 1991,” laughs Magome.

That year, Magome became part of a team that converted 60,000-hectare cattle farms into the Madikwe Game Reserve in the North West province.

He went on to serve as acting chief executive of formerly Bop Parks before joining SANParks in 1996.

While acting CEO of Bop Parks, he arranged for the first five white rhinos to be translocated (by road) to Khama Rhino Sanctuary in Botswana. 

Soon after joining SANParks, he helped move 30 white rhinos into the Okavango Delta, and they too have increased to over 2,000. 

Through this and other efforts, Botswana became home to a significant white rhino population, says Magome.

save rhinos Situated on the border with Botswana close to the Kalahari Desert, Madike Game Reserve has become the fifth-largest game park in South Africa, offering visitors a Big 5 safari experience over 750km². Magome directs Madikwe Futures Company (MFC), which raises funds to maintain the reserve from tourism and lodges. (Photo: Courtesy of Flowcom / Wikimedia Commons)



After SANParks, Magome spent a year in Cameroon, followed by two years in Malawi and Zambia, where he was inspired by what had been done to combat wildlife crime.

Malawi, once considered a capital for trafficking wildlife products, had effectively addressed wildlife crime within four years through partnerships between the state and various non-profit entities. 

“Poachers and traffickers were snowed under by an avalanche of multi-sectoral teams. This included changing policies and laws through to working with the police at crime scenes to help secure prosecutions,” says Magome.

“Arrests were followed with poachers spending time in jail. No deterrent is stronger than doing time.”

In stark contrast, in the decade from 2013 to 2023, South Africa’s criminal justice system has let poachers and traffickers kill rhinos and traffic their horns with relative ease, says Magome.

The same applies to other environmental crimes, ranging from littering to serious water pollution affecting the entire South African landscape.

Private prosecution


Against this backdrop, Magome says he was encouraged by the ground-breaking private prosecution and conviction in 2019 of British Petroleum SA for building 17 fuel stations in Gauteng without proper environmental assessments and authorisations.

The case against BP was initiated by a small legal entity, Uzani Environmental Advocacy CC, set up by a lawyer, Gideon (Kallie) Erasmus. It was the first-ever successful private prosecution in South Africa of an oil giant for environmental offences using our environmental laws.

“Through Uzani, Gideon demonstrated that private prosecution can indeed complement the state in fighting environmental crimes. The battle is not lost, and the war can be won.”

Currently, the dehorning of rhinos is among the strategies adopted to curb rhino poaching in South Africa.

But dehorning is not foolproof – even dehorned rhinos fall victim to poachers, says Magome. Nor is fortress-style protection a viable long-term solution due to costs.

Reducing the demand for horns is key, says Magome. He is likely to elaborate on this at the forthcoming Oppenheimer Conference.

And he may well quote Richard Emslie, a rhino expert for the IUCN’s Species Survival Commission, who describes anti-poaching efforts as a focus on the front of rhinos (to save their horns) as opposed to a focus on the rear of the rhinos (where they push out calves).

“Focusing on their rear means moving them to areas where they can safely breed,” says Magome.

“And if we improve policing technology, work with law enforcement officers on collecting evidence on arrests, on sentencing, and on monitoring convicted rhino poachers (after their release from prison), we could significantly reduce poaching,” he says.

“What we need is focus, sheer will and determination to change bad situations.” DM

This story was produced with support from Jive Media Africa, science communication partner to Oppenheimer Generations Research and Conservation.

Rhino poaching on the wane since 2015


There has been a decrease in rhino poaching in Africa from 2015 through to the end of 2022. This is according to a report soon to be released by the African Rhino Specialist Group (AfRSG) of the International Union Conservation of Nature (IUCN).

The AfRSG has also reported an increase in African rhinos from 22,137 at the end of 2021 to more than 23,000 at the end of 2022. These statistics are due to be released on World Rhino Day (September 2023).

Click here to view the latest available statistics.

Categories:

Tags: