Dailymaverick logo

South Africa

This article is more than a year old

South Africa

Proposed site for Muizenberg homeless shelter ‘could affect tourism, economic activity’

City of Cape Town says there is a desperate need for shelters, but no decision has been taken yet.
Proposed site for Muizenberg homeless shelter ‘could affect tourism, economic activity’

A parking lot in Muizenberg has been suggested as the site of the City of Cape Town’s new Safe Space shelter. The 1,141m² property is located in Sidmouth Road, close to the popular Surfers’ Corner beach, restaurants and surf stores. The shelter, which will be run in partnership with welfare organisation U-turn, will have at least 60 beds.

At a meeting on 15  July, subcouncil 19, which includes Muizenberg, approved a proposal from the City’s property management department that the parking lot be handed over from the Safety and Security directorate to the Community, Arts and Culture directorate. The plan is to create a Safe Space “designed to provide dignified transitional shelter and extensive social interventions aimed at helping homeless individuals move away from life on the streets”.

The transfer has also been approved by other directorates, according to City of Cape Town spokesperson Luthando Tyhalibongo.

In a statement, Simon Roberts, the chairperson of the Muizenberg Improvement District (MID), said the MID supported the shelter but was concerned about the proposed location as it could affect tourism and economic activity.

“This is the last available A-grade erf that can be developed to enhance our area,” he said. He said the MID wanted a full public participation process before a location was chosen.

“The public have not been informed, educated or consulted on this,” he said.

Tyhalibongo said a final decision had not yet been taken.

Read more: Families evicted in 2011 to make way for mall still waiting for promised homes

He said the City noted the concern about the economic impact shelters could have, but “there is a desperate need for shelters across the city, including in Muizenberg, in order to accommodate people who have taken up occupation in many of our public places, including under bridges and in the Muizenberg Park”.

He said the Western Cape High Court had said shelters should be located close to where the people involved earned an income, “and this constrains the choice of locality for suitable shelter space in the city to ensure that our homeless persons are offered a suitable path out of homelessness and off the streets”.

Tyhalibongo said U-turn would be entitled to apply to lease this site, and if the City considered the application, the lease would be advertised for public comment. DM

First published by GroundUp.

​​Daily Maverick’s journalism is funded by the contributions of our Maverick Insider members. If you appreciate our work, then join our membership community. Defending Democracy is an everyday effort. Be part of it. Become a Maverick Insider.

Comments (7)

minnaar Jul 18, 2024, 11:17 AM

As one expected, the "not-in-my-backyard' crowd jumped up to shout with very little positive contribution to the problem...

David Jeannot Jul 18, 2024, 10:27 AM

I enjoy surfing Muizenberg in the winter, I go often on weekends and find Surfer's Corner a hub of activity which includes South Africans from all walks of life, local surfers and internationals coming in to learn how to surf. It really is a positive scene and healthy economically. I'd imagine that local businesses are benefitting from this dynamic and jobs are created. It should be fostered.

samuelbowker Jul 18, 2024, 09:20 AM

The benefit vs damage ratio to the local businesses, property values, short term rentals and crime rate doesn't add up - which makes one question how this was approved, by whom and why, and what did they stand to benefit. Contrary to popular belief the City of Cape Town is quite open to bribery, especially in the property zoning/development/approval and heritage building protection spheres. I knew a renovator who was told R20,000 would guarantee him approval to make whatever changes he liked to a heritage designated building. I'm convinced this happens on a much larger scale around the city, especially with larger property developments. This instance is quite likely related to someone along the line gaining a benefit.

cynthedw Jul 18, 2024, 07:46 AM

Homelessness and unusable public spaces will be the death of tourism in Muizenberg. Keeping people off the streets and providing dignity and a path to move forward under the guidance of U-turn is the only way forward.

cynthedw Jul 18, 2024, 07:46 AM

Homelessness and unusable public spaces will be the death of tourism in Muizenberg. Keeping people off the streets and providing dignity and a path to move forward under the guidance of U-turn is the only way forward.

Jeremy Collins Jul 17, 2024, 09:32 PM

The Safe Spaces in the city, covered recently in DM, give us a fairly clear indication of where this is going. With little regard for the social and economic impact, the city will plough this project through and pat themselves on the back. But all they’re doing is creating a semi-privatised holding camp for homeless people, who will live in hokkies and hang around in far greater numbers than they do currently - there’s no real solution here.

Notinmyname Fang Jul 17, 2024, 07:39 PM

There are acres of land on the Cape Flats unused. Now we use prime real estate in a tourism destination for homeless shelter. Please do the maths, we need jobs in the area. Shelters are not the priority.

cynthedw Jul 18, 2024, 07:48 AM

Moving people far distances from work with no money or access to work is what we used to call apartheid. Homeless shouldnt strip people of their humanity.