Dailymaverick logo

Maverick News

This article is more than a year old

Maverick News

Six dead and 48 missing in devastating George building collapse

Recovery operations are under way in the Southern Cape town of George following a building collapse on Monday which has left six dead, 26 removed from the rubble and 48 unaccounted for.
Six dead and 48 missing in devastating George building collapse The debris after a building under construction collapsed in George. (Photo: Stamhoof Brendon Torob Adams / Facebook)

As rescue efforts at the collapsed construction site enter their second day, 48 people remain trapped under the rubble. Authorities have yet to identify the developers responsible for the site.

Rescue teams are in a race against time to retrieve as many trapped workers as possible from beneath the rubble. 

As of 12pm on Tuesday, six of the 27 patients removed from the collapsed building had been declared deceased, while another 48 people who were present at the time of the collapse remained unaccounted for. 

Relatives and loved ones of the trapped workers were escorted to a waiting room at the civic centre, where they received psychosocial support services. As the rescue drags on, fear and uncertainty fill their every moment. 

George mayor Leon van Wyk said he did not know the developers, engineers and contractors responsible for the site, despite his office being across the road from where the tragic incident happened. “Unfortunately, I don’t know those names at this stage,” he told a Daily Maverick reporter. 

“I think we need to establish [the names] from the Department of Labour. I personally do not know.” 

Municipal manager Dr Michele Gratz agreed with the mayor, adding the current focus of the authorities was on rescuing the trapped workers. 

Van Wyk and Gratz were addressing a press briefing on Tuesday alongside Western Cape Premier Alan Winde; Anton Bredell, Western Cape MEC of Local Government and Environmental Affairs; Colin Deiner, chief director of the provincial Disaster Management Services; and Memory Booysen, executive mayor of Garden Route District Municipality.

“What I also have put in place through the director general… [is] already getting an investigation going. We have to make sure that while [the rescue] is happening we have got specialist engineers on site because we have to find out why this happened and how it happened. Of course, obviously the building goes through planning processes at the municipality level, and all those processes obviously were being followed, but… we have to find out exactly why a building like this collapses,” said Winde.

“We have to make sure that no stone will be left unturned.”

Rescue effort

Various rescue teams are involved in the operation in George, including teams from the City of Cape Town, Breedevallei tech rescue, Search and Rescue South Africa (Sarza), the South African Police Service and nonprofit Gift of the Givers. There are currently about 111 professionals on site, according to Winde.

Speaking on yesterday’s rescue efforts, Deiner said, “We were actually hearing people shouting through the rubble, so that was the first point. And then the dogs come in and the dogs do a verification. Once the dogs have verified that there’s somebody, we have high-tech equipment that we can actually start triangulating and pinpointing where someone is trapped.”

Deiner explained that the international standard for the length of this type of rescue effort is three days. “In other words, we treat everybody as still alive and we try and rescue everybody, so that’s what we’ve been doing. 

“We’ll make a call after three days [of] where we stand… We’re going to give the absolute maximum time to see how many people we can rescue.”

The rescuers are currently in contact with 11 people beneath the rubble, including four who are trapped in a basement area. Deiner estimated that it would take most of the day to rescue the people trapped in the basement.

Later in the day, the rescue teams will start a process of “delayering”, he continued. “That would mean that we would then start lifting the different floors off each other, and the reason we do that is that there’s a possibility that people could still be alive…”

Community support

As the rescue teams diligently worked through the rubble, community members continued to show their support by bringing an abundance of snacks and refreshments, generously sharing words of encouragement and offering heartfelt prayers for the safety and well-being of those involved in the rescue operation.

Update from Monday

Workers are being freed from a collapsed building in George with help from emergency services from as far as Worcester and the Gift of the Givers. 

building collapse george Emergency services and police at the site, trying to free trapped workers. (Photo: Supplied)



building collapse george This building under construction collapsed in George, Western Cape, trapping workers. (Photo: Supplied)



building collapse george This is the building that collapsed in George, Western Cape. (Photo: Supplied)



building collapse george Dust billows after the building collapsed. (Photo: Stamhoof Brendon Torob Adams / Facebook)



Just before 2.30pm on Monday, 6 May, the multi-storey building collapsed at 75 Victoria Street. Emergency services have been on scene, trying to rescue trapped workers.

Gift of the Givers teams have been dispatched to the building, which was under construction. The building is privately owned.

building collapse george The scene after this building under construction collapsed in George, Western Cape. (Photo: Supplied)



building collapse george The debris after a building under construction collapsed in George, Western Cape. Emergency services are at the site, trying to free trapped workers. (Photo: Stamhoof Brendon Torob Adams / Facebook)



The Western Cape provincial government said Premier Alan Winde and his MECs were being briefed on the incident. “All the necessary support has been offered to emergency personnel to expedite their response. At the moment, officials are focused on saving lives. This is our top priority at this stage,” said Winde. 

The province sent personnel and emergency response support to assist with operations.

According to a George municipality update last night, 53 emergency personnel were on their way from the City of Cape Town and Worcester Disaster Services. Chief Director of Western Cape Disaster Services Colin Deiner will be on site as soon as possible.

Gift of the Givers’ representative in the Southern Cape Mario Ferreira told Daily Maverick the mood at the scene was “very sombre”. There had been some communication between rescue officials and those still trapped. The humanitarian organisations’ sniffer dogs were headed to the scene to help with operations.

Supplies


George municipality said police, ambulance services and staff from the Garden Route District Municipality were at the scene, which involved ‘multiple’ patients. The municipality has said people wishing to provide supplies such as drinking water, energy drinks and food could deliver, via Ivy Street, at 79 Victoria Street, Delplan Consulting. A municipal worker would be there to collect donations.

The DA’s constituency head in George, MP Mimmy Gondwe, said: “The DA in George would like to thank the emergency personnel for their swift response to this tragic incident and will keep monitoring the situation with a view to offering any form of assistance and support.” DM

This article was updated at 1.30pm on 7 May 2024.

Comments (5)

reyemedar@yahoo.com.au May 9, 2024, 12:08 PM

I was born and raised in George but was transferred by the company for to Australia many years ago. Visited my hometown many times over the years but found odd businesses that caused the destruction of the town itself. Thousands of houses were demolished. Kerkhof Street where I grew up is now a business area. We lived directly opposite the cemetery. The Outeniqua High School is a fine and famous school. now just over 100 years old.

dugallan@icloud.com May 8, 2024, 09:39 AM

The priorities are to rescue all those trapped. I really feel for the families. In my unqualified opinion there could be three scenarios that caused the collapse. 1) Inferior workmanship. 2) Inferior materials 3) One or more of the supporting pillars in the basement caved in. Either through damage by 3rd parties unknown or unstable foundations. It will be interesting to see what the future holds as the rescue of those trapped must take precedence over collecting evidence.

sandybotha May 7, 2024, 06:35 PM

The contractors etc. are clearly visible on google street view before breaking ground but is also visible in one of the photos above so there's no mistake. How they can say no-one knows who to point fingers at, I don't know. Proposed future name: NEO 75 Victoria Luxury Apartments + website neovictoria and coza. NT NEOTREND GROUP / ICE Projects / RealNet George (R vd Walt 0609975266) + email

Kenneth FAKUDE May 8, 2024, 12:38 AM

I smell a rat, the building was approved by municipal engineers but the mayor does not know the developers including the people who applied for the construction, what about taking a cell phone and asking the engineers? How do they know the exact number of people who were working on site if they don't know the responsible people for the construction? Asking for names of the victims will obviously be a tall order. Are these the jobs promised on the campaign trail? The DA must clearly visit their good governance record this is definitely not good governance at all. The silence from government building inspectors is deafening. We are already being told of how good the rescue plan is, where is the best preventive plan? A million jobs in 5 years some say, next time we must hear a million good quality and safe jobs please. If this happens on a DA led city we can expect worse on the non DA led cities where corruption is the order of the day.

Ina Loots May 7, 2024, 05:18 PM

Much too early to speculate about "Chines inferior materials", BEE, construction mafia, etc etc. One cannot see from the photos whether the superstructure was loadbearing brickwork, which is perfectly acceptable provided the structural design is competently done, or reinforced concrete columns that supported the floor slabs. The photos do show that structure and brickwork was up to 4th level, with only the roof slab under construction. This implies 80-90% of the load already on the structure and foundations. If the roof slab was being cast on the day of the collapse (which we do not yet know) the additional weight might have led to the lowest columns being overstressed, particularly if an incorrect concrete mix was used and this was not picked up by the concrete test regime (a possibility, but unlikely if competent contractor and structural engineer were involved (which we do not yet know). The municipal building inspectorate should have all the names of Owner, Architect, Structural Engineer and Contractor, as part of the approval process. It is unlikely that a building of this size would have been ignored by the building inspectorate whilst under construction. Only a detailed forensic structural engineering investigation will tell us what happened.

Kevin Potgieter May 7, 2024, 05:01 PM

Winde - “We have to make sure that no stone will be left unturned.” Seriously? A bit close to the bone?