Dailymaverick logo

Opinionistas

This is an opinion piece.
The views expressed are not that of Daily Maverick.....

This article is more than a year old

We finally have a Cabinet — now let’s get down to business

After all the weeks of panic and uncertainty, I believe this is mostly a good Cabinet and a win-win situation for all involved.

Yes, it took a while and it was touch and go at times, but this was a gigantic effort. Not many countries can get 11 very diverse parties to agree to form a coalition in less than a month.

It was interesting to see the intricate dance President Cyril Ramaphosa performed to get this to work. One measure was to enlarge the Cabinet by adding two more positions and splitting a few ministries. The sensitive land reform portfolio had to be split from the DA-controlled agriculture ministry for obvious reasons. 

(While I’m on agriculture: Many have wondered why the DA was so keen to get the agriculture ministry when the closest John Steenhuisen most probably ever got to farming was buying eggs and rotisserie chickens at Woolies.  The answer lies not so much in farming, but in the farmers, particularly the ones who voted for the FF+. It is one of the few potential growth points for the DA.)

But I digress. 

Splitting mineral resources from energy — something I suggested in a column more than a year ago — was well overdue and the right decision. Ramaphosa had to retain former secretary-general of the ANC, Gwede Mantashe, in his Cabinet and Mantashe’s experience serves him well in mining, but thankfully he no longer has anything to do with energy — green or otherwise. 

Interestingly, Pravin Gordhan’s final act before his retirement was to propose the scrapping of the public enterprise portfolio, which Ramaphosa did.   

New faces


If you don’t recognise many of the faces, you are not alone. More than half of the 32 ministers in the Cabinet are new — in part because the occupants of the 12 seats occupied by the non-ANC (we can no longer call them opposition) parties who, apart from Patricia de Lille, had never served in the Cabinet.

The ANC has six new ministers. Most importantly, Ramaphosa got rid of almost all those mentioned in the Zondo commission report on State Capture.  

Wisely, Ramaphosa retained some of the more seasoned ministers. The experienced Enoch Godongwana was needed as minister of finance to stabilise the markets and calm down jittery investors. The respected Barbara Creecy was moved to transport and although this is a loss for the environment department, it is important to have someone of her calibre to deal with the troublesome Transnet, Spoornet and SAA. Equally, keeping Kgosientsho Ramokgopa to deal with Eskom and the Department of Electricity and Energy. 

Aaron Motsoaledi returns to the Department of Health after a stint at home affairs (by the way, good luck to Leon Schreiber with that prickly pear). Of course, Motsoaledi came up with the early formulations of the National Health Insurance (NHI), so one can only assume that he will double down on the implementation of the recently passed legislation despite the inevitable court cases.

Human settlements stayed with Mmamoloko Kubayi, tourism with Auntie Pat (de Lille) and Blade Nzimande retained science and technology, albeit without higher education. 

Velinkosi Hlabisa, the leader of the IFP, makes sense in cooperative governance and traditional affairs. The jury is out on Pieter Groenewald in correctional services and Gayton McKenzie in sport — although I enjoyed his tweet (with a photo of him in sports gear) immediately after the announcement saying that he can’t respond to all the good wishes since he was already working.

So now they have to make it work. 

In the next few days, the executive will have a lekgotla to decide on priorities for the country. They must also agree on a conflict resolution mechanism. 

After all the weeks of panic and uncertainty, I believe this is mostly a good Cabinet and a win-win situation for all involved. Now, can we please get down to business and fix the country? Oh, and spare a thought for the President, who will have his hands full with all the mega egos in the Cabinet room. DM

Daily Maverick’s journalism is funded by the contributions of our Maverick Insider members. If you appreciate our work, then join our membership community. Defending Democracy is an everyday effort. Be part of it. Become a Maverick Insider.

Comments (8)

Jeremy Jul 8, 2024, 02:20 PM

An anodyne commentary if ever there was one. The most credible contribution in the whole article lies in the last paragraph. " Now, can we please get down to business and fix the country?" Yes, of course we can, if this bloated cabinet of mostly incompetent re-cycled ANC sycophants and CR do their work honestly, unleash the Economy and put South Africa First!

Richard Worthington Jul 8, 2024, 12:09 PM

Some very wishful thinking in the assertion that Minister Mantashe "no longer has anything to do with energy" - if only! As the Minister of Mineral and Petroleum Resources he can be expected to push for the adoption of the SA National Petroleum Company Bill - with aspirations for a new state-owned oil refinery - as well as the Gas Masterplan, which proposes large-scale gas-fired electricity generation...

Rudolph Oosthuizen Jul 8, 2024, 11:08 AM

This post offers only well known facts and no new insights. The introductory statement: "mostly a good Cabinet and a win-win situation for all involved" creates an expectation for the reader. Unfortunately it just remains two unsubstantiated, highly debatable points. Melanie, this post is simply just "padding". Are you committed to submit a certain number of posts per month?

Karl Sittlinger Jul 8, 2024, 10:55 AM

A little scary that you endorse a man such as Mantashe. Apart from supporting Zuma including the entire Nkandla debacle for years and that he single handedly held back renewable energy and exasperated loadshedding significantly, he has been a failure in his current portfolio. Is this the "experience" you are referring to? Why do you persist in supporting the ANC on topics that are clearly a catastrophe? A great article showing the lackluster performance of Mantashe can be found on DM with the title "Data shows mining SA output declines in May, while Mantashe punts problematic law".

e.janerosenthal Jul 8, 2024, 10:41 AM

I posted a comment 3 hours ago, which is still "being moderated". What's to moderate? I'm getting the message that this comments column's moderators have a problem with women ? Some such? Please publish my original comment. Or tell me why not.

Middle aged Mike Jul 8, 2024, 08:33 AM

"Ramaphosa had to retain former secretary-general of the ANC, Gwede Mantashe, in his Cabinet and Mantashe’s experience serves him well in mining" This must be peak delusion. During his tenure the mining industry has seen a precipitous decline. What possible upside could our favourite little Stalinist bring to the portfolio?

louis viljee Jul 8, 2024, 08:30 AM

Thanks Melanie. Cobbling together a cabinet from such diverse parties and egos is indeed almost a miracle. If we voters continue to engage in a spirit of democratic cooperation, we can get the wheels moving. We all look forward to better days and only in community of purpose can we get there. Petty egos and partisanship only leads to continued decay as Gauteng sadly demonstrates.

Rod MacLeod Jul 8, 2024, 07:31 AM

" ... in part because the occupants of the 12 seats occupied by the non-ANC (we can no longer call them opposition) parties ... " Ah, Melanie, you just said a mouthful. No opposition for a party that just lost its majority! Masterful sleight of hand by the person you so adore!