Dailymaverick logo

Business Maverick

Business Maverick

We will stop the bleeding, Transnet CEO tells Joburg Mining Indaba

We will stop the bleeding, Transnet CEO tells Joburg Mining Indaba
The CEO of state-run logistics company Transnet struck the rights notes at the Joburg Mining Indaba on Wednesday, a refreshing contrast from her predecessor’s past appearances at the conference.

When former Transnet CEO Portia Derby addressed the Joburg Mining Indaba two years ago, she came across as tone-deaf to the cries of an industry reeling from the mounting failures of the state-owned enterprise (SOE), which were costing the economy billions of rands a year in lost export revenue under her watch.

Derby said that Transnet’s strategic agenda was to allocate any new rail and port capacity to emerging black miners – a vision set out as the existing infrastructure was crumbling and the SOE had no capital for new capacity.

Michelle Phillips, who has the arduous task of turning this failing ship around, has struck a completely different tone.

“We are going to stop the bleeding,” she told the Indaba. Simply acknowledging that cash was bleeding was a stark departure from her predecessor.

“The balance sheet is not what it should be. I (Transnet) sit with up to R67-billion of what I refer to as ‘ineffective debt.’ It’s money that has been borrowed for the purpose of buying assets to resource this network and they did not do that,” she said.

Effectively, money that was borrowed and then misspent, squandered or stolen.

Phillips recently told Parliament that the amount of “ineffective” debt amounted to R60-billion, so the estimate appears to be rising.

Public consultation


On the issue of tariffs for Transnet’s services, Phillips said the regulator – which in this case is now the Ministry of Transport – would decide in a public consultation process.

“This is why we asked the public to be part of this consultation process ... so it’s not a bad thing that people are complaining about tariffs,” Phillips said. The ultimate aim, she said, was for pricing that “the market can bear.”

Eskom Holdings Group CEO Dan Marokane was blunter and less diplomatic in this regard.

The state-run power utility has applied to the National Energy Regulator of SA (Nersa) for big tariff hikes over the next three years of 36.15%, 11.81% and then 9.1%.

Read more: What you need to know about Eskom’s retail tariff plan application

“I know it is an emotive subject, but we need to deal with it once and for all,” Marokane told the Indaba, noting Eskom’s mounting spending plans and burdens such as R80-billion in unpaid municipal debt.

Still, the overall mood at the 2024 edition of the Joburg Indaba is the most upbeat it has been in years, and both Transnet and Eskom – which has not implemented nationwide rolling blackouts since late March – are part of that story.

‘Positive vibe’


“There is certainly a positive vibe this year,” Mzila Mthenjane, the CEO of the Minerals Council South Africa, the main umbrella group for the mining industry, told Daily Maverick in an interview on the sidelines of the conference.

He noted Tuesday’s announcement of the launch of the second phase of the government/business partnership focused on power, logistics and crime/corruption – the trifecta of woes seen as the main constraint to growth in Africa’s most industrialised economy.

The aim is high with the hope that such initiatives will translate into economic growth of as much as 3.3% by the end of 2025 compared with expected growth this year of only around 1.0%. 

Read more: Heavy hitter CEOs target eye-watering economic growth by end of 2025 and a million jobs by 2030

“But even before that, the fact that we have been seeing improvements on the electricity side and on the logistics – Michelle was honest but it’s stabilising. Those two things are quite critical,” Mthenjane said. 

For South Africa’s mining sector, which has been in a state of long-term decline and falling investment, there are flickering lights at the end of the tunnel. DM