Daily Maverick
Dailymaverick logo

Africa

Africa, Maverick Citizen

Will Emmerson Mnangagwa walk the talk and make Zimbabwe great again?

Will Emmerson Mnangagwa walk the talk and make Zimbabwe great again?
A man walks past an election banner of President Emmerson Mnangagwa in Harare, Zimbabwe, 29 May 2023. (Photo: EPA-EFE / Arron Ufumeli)
Phillip van Niekerk
By Phillip van Niekerk
1 Jun 2023
Facebook
1
The August elections are an opportunity that Mnangagwa should grasp to restore trust and confidence between the government and the international community, but compensation to unpaid investors, including farmers and miners, is key to re-engagement.

The potential restoration of Zimbabwe as a member of good standing in the international community could be the biggest game-changer in Africa this year – but Zanu-PF has to take the opportunity that is being offered.

The dialogue over debt resolution and arrears clearance championed by African Development Bank President Akinwumi Adesina and facilitated by former Mozambique president Joaquim Chissano appears to be moving towards some kind of resolution.

“We know what needs to be done,” Adesina told the meeting. “We must move more rapidly now into speedy implementation on the ground.”

The key indicator of how serious Harare is in its promise to restore the rule of law will be its ability to pull off a free and fair election.

Zimbabwean President Emmerson Mnangagwa’s announcement this week that elections are to be held on 23 August was met with dismay in some quarters because the date was published before a series of electoral reforms could be enacted.

“This will have serious consequences not just for the credibility of the elections and for our political stability, but also for our economic development and international relations,” the legal think tank Veritas warned.

People attend the burial of national hero, Brigadier General (Rtd) Walter Kanhanga, presided by Zimbabwean President Emmerson Mnangagwa at the National Heroes Acre in Harare, Zimbabwe, 10 February 2023. (Photo: EPA-EFE / Arron Ufumeli)



Adesina and Chissano’s outreach included a visit last month to Washington, which broadly supports their initiative. The view was expressed in Congress and by the US Treasury that “concrete and measurable steps” will trigger the lifting of sanctions.

Mnangagwa has tried to reassure sceptical development partners and creditors by committing to the implementation of a package of reforms, including governance reforms, land tenure reforms, compensation of former farm owners and the resolution of bilateral investment protection agreements.

But can Mnangagwa walk the talk?

The ruling Zanu-PF has dashed hopes before – remember the optimism in 2018 after Mnangagwa overthrew Robert Mugabe in a military coup?

Reform of the vast patronage machine that has ravaged the country’s economy, collapsed the health and education sectors and turned hundreds of thousands of Zimbabweans into refugees in neighbouring states, is going to take a lot more than sweet words.

Read more in Daily Maverick: Zimbabwe at 43: Portents of a deepening authoritarian rule by Zanu-PF

What makes this time feel different is the passion and commitment of Adesina, whose stewardship of the African Development Bank has turned it into one of the most vibrant and effective institutions on the continent, and the diplomatic skills of Chissano, the former Frelimo fighter whose relationship with Zanu-PF goes back to the days of the liberation struggle.

Their engagement will make it harder for Zanu-PF to blame the former colonialists and bullying Americans if it fails to meet its promises.

Adesina insists that political reforms are an integral part of the debt restructuring package. “Success on the political and electoral reforms, and a free and fair election, are crucial to clear the pathway towards arrears clearance and debt resolution for Zimbabwe,” he said.

The ruling Zanu-PF party has a long history of abusing state institutions to muzzle and oppress the opposition. Two high-profile opposition leaders, Job Sikhala and Jacob Ngarivhume, are currently jailed on what critics say are politically motivated charges, while the voters’ roll has yet to be opened for public inspection with fewer than three months to the elections.

Zimbabwe’s electoral management body, the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (ZEC), remains one of the country’s least-trusted institutions, populated by former military officials who aren’t known for their impartiality.

With its privileged access to state resources, Zanu-PF is poised to win the upcoming general election, even without overt cheating. If they choose to use violence and intimidation once again, they will prove that the political and electoral playing field is unchanged since the time of Mugabe.
Leaving out mining investors could hamper efforts to attract blue-chip investors rather than the bottom feeders and rogues that currently pollute the Zimbabwean economy.

Adesina has made it clear that there will be no deal if there is another bad election: “The people of Zimbabwe and the international community will be watching very closely. The full weight of re-engagement… will depend not just on the election, but the entire electoral process that guarantees a credible election.”

This is an opportunity that Mnangagwa should grasp to restore trust and confidence between the government and the international community, but compensation to unpaid investors, including farmers and miners, is key to re-engagement.

A man walks past an election banner of President Emmerson Mnangagwa in Harare, Zimbabwe, 29 May 2023. (Photo: EPA-EFE / Arron Ufumeli)


Mountain of debt


Zimbabwe’s external debt is estimated at $14.04-billion, comprising $5.7-billion of bilateral debt, $2.6-billion of multilateral debt, $3.4-billion Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe debt and $2.3-billion in blocked funds.

Accumulated arrears were estimated at $6.3-billion at the end of September 2022 and are rising fast.

A deal on the arrears will enable Zimbabwe to access new lines of credit to surmount the catastrophic underperformance of what should be one of the best economies in Africa.

Read more in Daily Maverick: ‘Pathway to hope’: It’s time to give Zimbabwe back to the people

Adesina revealed that the bank has developed financial instruments to “fast-track and front-load” the promised $3.5-billion compensation to the white farmers as part of the debt-clearance programme.

What has been conspicuously absent from the debt talks is any proposal to compensate mining investors, who are owed more than $460-million by Harare after they won international arbitration cases arising from rights disputes.

The Zimbabwe Mining Development Company (ZMDC), which incurred exposures as a result of the cancellation of mining rights and the forceful removal, for instance, of Grandwell from the Marange diamond fields in 2016, is a 100% government-owned entity.

However, the state has been reluctant to assume ZMDC’s debts as it has done with other state-owned enterprises. Instead ZMDC has been involved in endless and costly litigation trying to overturn the arbitration awards.

Leaving out mining investors could hamper efforts to attract blue-chip investors rather than the bottom feeders and rogues that currently pollute the Zimbabwean economy.

Read more in Daily Maverick: Zimbabwe needs a second liberation – from the liberators themselves

The good news is that Zimbabwe’s ability to repay its debt and rebuild its economy has been enhanced by increased earnings from platinum and gold, while the country has also recently discovered extensive lithium deposits.

Some estimates indicate that Zimbabwe has the largest lithium reserves in Africa and the fifth-largest in the world, and Mnangagwa has signalled that mining and refining lithium ore is a focus of the Zimbabwe government.

The pieces are in place for a revival of Zimbabwe that would be a much-needed boost for the entire southern African region.

The choice now is Mnangagwa’s. Which legacy will he opt for? DM

Phillip van Niekerk is the editor of Africa Unscrambled, a newsletter covering the continent in a way you won’t read anywhere else. He is also the editorial director of Scrolla.Africa. Get Unscrambled by signing up right here.

Categories:

Tags: